The Most Valuable Bo Jackson Cards of All Time

To start this list off strong, we have the quintessential Bo Jackson grail. Topps Tiffany cards were limited edition collectors’ sets from 1984-1991, and they were printed on a premium card stock. 1986 Tiffany has a print run of around 5,000, and there are only 37 known PSA 10s of this card.  If you’ve seen one of these in person, you know just how much they pop out. Jackson’s ‘86 Tiffany has sold for as high as $14,000, but newer sales range from $10,000-12,000.

Our next card features Bo with a very familiar face. Jackson and Mike Trout may be the two most collected outfielders of their generation, and both are exceptional athletes. Typically, Bo is paired with his era’s players on dual-autographed cards, so it is neat to see one where he’s next to a modern superstar. The PSA 10 grade is also a major plus for this thicker card, so this one is an all-around banger.

Since its inception, the Precious Metal Gems (PMG) insert has been a favorite of many modern basketball and football collectors. While Mr. Jackson doesn’t have any PMGs from his playing days, he did appear in the 2012 Fleer Retro Collegiate set. This card, which shows #34 in his Auburn uniform, sold for over $6,000 in May.

Is there a single card with more broken tackles on it than this one? This stunner from 2007 SP Chirography showcases four masters of the backfield; all of them provide an on-card signature on this 1/1 copy. Bo is the only player on this card that’s not in the Hall of Fame. We’ll let you decide if he would be in Canton had he finished a full career in the NFL.

Pack-issued autographs were not yet in circulation during Bo’s early years. So, seeing his Topps Traded rookie with a sweet signature is super neat. When paired with a perfect PSA 10/AUTO 10 grade, you have a grail card for any Bo Jackson collector. While this 10 sold for over $3,500, a PSA 9/AUTO 10 can be picked up in the $500-700 range.

This one is another 80s card that was hard to obtain a PSA 10 grade. Even still, Bo’s Topps Football rookie has a population of 556, which is drastically higher than his Tiffany RC.  

Jackson was famously drafted first overall by the Tampa Bay Buccaneers in 1986, but he elected to begin his professional career in the MLB. Two years later, the L.A. Raiders drafted him in the seventh round, and the rest is history.

Number seven is a misprinted card that seldomly surfaces. This 1986 Donruss is one of Bo’s earliest cards, and it notes one of his early homers in Royals Stadium. This copy is special because the “Highlights” icon is printed in white instead of yellow; in fact, the card is only a POP 6 as a PSA 10, marking a huge rarity from the junk wax era.

This card makes us wonder how the hobby would react if Bo was a rookie today. He also has a card in the 2019 and 2020 Prizm set, but the 1/1s have not surfaced. The Black Finite parallel perfectly contrasts with the iconic Raiders’ black and silver, so this one is a great addition to any Bo Jackson collection.

This Immaculate patch autograph is one of the few we’ve seen with a game-worn piece of memorabilia. It’s also a prime example of buying the card and not the grade. This 1/1 last sold for $2,000 in a November 2022 Goldin Auction.

The pinnacle of athletic ability resides on this card. Fans can go back and forth on who was the better athlete, but one thing is for certain: we may never see two-sport dominance like this ever again. In recent years, players like Kyler Murray and Russell Wilson have competed in both football and baseball, but neither has taken it to the level that Bo and Deion did. What a tremendous dual autograph.